CF Trust Meeting Point

Message Boards for the CF Trust » Connect - Adults Message Board

Topic: Awful article in the daily mail
Replies: 24   Pages: 2   Last Post: 05-Dec-2006 18:49 by: Bill H

Reply to this Topic Reply to this Topic
Search Forum Search Forum

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List
Replies: 24   Pages: 2   [ Previous | 1 2 ]
ros

Posts: 31
From: Cambridge
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 03-Dec-2006 19:24
  Reply

what do people think about sending a mass email to the daily mail, with lots of signatures from us all, complaining about such a ridiculous artical? I know they probably won't care a damn but if we get lots of people to sign, we might be able to force them to apologise, just so that they get to look all caring and sharing! I hate to see people spreadignn misleading and down right ridiclous information.

Emmie

Posts: 34
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 03-Dec-2006 20:02
  Reply

Wooo I'm really going to put the cat among the pigeons here I think! I bought a copy of this paper in order to get some change for a parking meter (not intending to read it!). When I saw the article by Amanda Patell I decided to read it, thinking "Oh here we go...this will be a load of b*llocks". Then I read on and actually I found it fairly interesting.

I don't think anyone has the right to tell a family how they should lead their lives, those decisions are totally personal and individual. However I didn't personally feel insulted by this article in the way that others appear to have been. As far as I can see, she was writing in her personal column and simply mulling over the difficulties that the Brown family will face in combining PM-ship of one of the leading countries in the world and also the world of CF.

I really hope that little Fraser will have a really healthy childhood without many CF-related problems. However there is no getting away from the fact that CF is an illnes which is exceptionally labour-intensive and also emotionally intensive to deal with. At the same time, being Prime Minister is one of the most stressful, labour-intensive and demanding jobs in the world. The country makes demands which have to be placed above one's personal situation, one which involves significant lengths of time abroad or away from home, and one in which it would often be very difficult to drop commitments in the event of personal emergencies. That's not to say that CF and Premiership can't be combined, but I don't see the harm in considering the difficulties that this combination presents either.

My father was an officer in the Royal Navy when my brother and I were born with CF two years apart. For a couple of years my Dad continued as normal...going away to sea for weeks on end, being ready to be called up at any time in the event of a conflict, going away on training events, etc. But my brother and I were both very unwell during those years and my Mum was not only looking after us all day, but was up in the night several times giving us physio as well. Even without the hospital stays and treatent regime, it was a huge amount emotionally for my Mum to cope with alone and she wasn't fortunate enough to have a good family/friend support work to help out.

In the end the navy gave my Dad compassionate discharge so he could follow a career path that was better suited to supporting my Mum and helping with our care. He wanted to be involved in doing our physio whenever he could and helping with our treatments.

I really hope that Fraser will keep very healthy (although how they can say that someone has "mild" CF at the age of only a few months confuses me) and hopefully the Brown family will have a fantastic support network. Whether they can cope with combining the role of PM and living with CF is completely up to them and I wish them every luck with whatever they decide. But at the same time I'm not insulted when someone expresses understanding of what a huge deal CF is for families to live with and muses about how this may affect someone's career.

NorthernStar

Posts: 24
Registered: 02-Dec-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 03-Dec-2006 20:32
  Reply

> But at the same time I'm not insulted when
> someone expresses understanding of what a huge deal
> CF is for families to live with and muses about how
> this may affect someone's career.

I don't think we read the same article. I didn't see any understanding of CF or what it's like to have a child with CF and to try and juggle work and family commitments. I felt that the article was presumptuous and the child's diagnosis was just being used an an opportunity to shaft Brown. Opportunism at its worst.

tracie

Posts: 148
From: west midlands
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 03-Dec-2006 20:44
  Reply

I think we should also remember, it's not just about familys with cf in it but about the people who have cf themselves, im just a carer for my son, I hate it but i have to live with it and deal with it, this is nothing compared with what my son and so many others have to go through, sorry to say but forget the sympathy for the Brown's it is after all Frazier that is going to have to live with this awful illness

Bill H

Posts: 11
From: Scotland
Registered: 30-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 04-Dec-2006 10:28
  Reply

Not worth worrying about. AP couldn't give at toss about PWCF or the Browns, merely writing drivel for political reasons.

I'm happy for someone to have a pop at this government's record or Brown's bid to be PM but this is just typical British tabloid smut dressed up as patronising concern for the Browns.

Emmie

Posts: 34
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 04-Dec-2006 14:51
  Reply

Hmmm I'm now reading the article in a totally different light! If all it was is a way of attacking Gordon Brown and undermining his ability to be leader, then that is totally below the belt. Ah well, I don't think anyone will be taking any serious notice of it anyway which is good!

robsons

Posts: 2
From: Loughborough
Registered: 30-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 04-Dec-2006 16:21
  Reply

Shocking report, my Dad brought me and my two sisters up when my mum left at the age of 11, i'm 25 now and still going strong. He has his own business and still managed to take me to clinics and hospital. I'm sure Mrs Brown will have lots of help, good luck to them and wouldn't listen to what bored people write in the papers.

DJ

Posts: 5
From: Midlands
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 04-Dec-2006 19:34
  Reply

I really disagree that this article has any valid point to make. It shows a complete lack of understanding for what it means to be a parent of a newly-diagnosed baby - a completely different prospect from what it was 20 years ago. It shows no hope, and seems to assume that Fraser's condition is going to spiral downwards immediately.

I can't stand this hateful paper as you might gather, and agree that it is horrendous opportunism. The way it inadvertently equates Down's syndrome to CF is also breathtaking.

I also contest that nobody will take any notice. The Daily Mail has circulation figures of over 2.3 million, let alone the number that actually read it. In contrast, The Guardian sells under 400,000.

Personally, I would welcome any move to get an apology out of the Daily Mail - alternatively, if anybody has Amanda Platell's email address please could you stick it on here?

tracie

Posts: 148
From: west midlands
Registered: 06-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 04-Dec-2006 20:10
  Reply

DJ if you scroll down from the article there is a section where you can post your comments, you will notice some people all ready have, hope this is of help

Bill H

Posts: 11
From: Scotland
Registered: 30-Nov-2006
Re: Awful article in the daily mail
Posted: 05-Dec-2006 18:49
  Reply

DJ and Ros

I tried commenting on this tripe written by AP but unsurprisingly it looks as if the website is not listing anymore criticism.